Tague Family
Jeff Tague
Senior Pastor

Jeff grew up in central Indiana before graduating from Cedarville University in Ohio.  He pastored for 6 years in Ohio after graduation.  In June 1997, God brought him back to Indiana to pastor at Calvary.  His primary focus at Calvary is preaching and teaching at our weekend services, shepherding the people of Calvary, leading the staff, and providing the overall vision of the church. 

He has been married to his wife Janna since 1990.  They have a son, Caleb and a daughter, Sara at home; and a married daughter, Rachael (David).

Jeff’s passions include expository preaching that enables people to see and respond to the greatness of God; teaching and living the doctrines of grace.  He also enjoys reading widely (including anything Spurgeon); and also enjoys sports of all kinds.

Craig Family

Mark Craig
Associate Pastor

Mark grew up in the Indianapolis area and joined the pastoral staff of Calvary in 2004.  He graduated from Cedarville University and Grand Rapids Seminary.  He has served the Lord as a youth pastor at Temple Baptist Church in Portsmouth, Ohio, and as the pastor of Friendship Church in Greenwood, Indiana.  Pastor Mark’s gifts and passion center on helping people functionally become more and more like Jesus.  His primary responsibilities include directing Calvary’s missions and local outreach; teaching and training of our lay staff; and administration.

He has been married to his wife Colleen since 1985.  They have two adult children, Matthew and Kristen, both living in Florida.

Mark also enjoys outdoor sports – including disc golf at our church course – and travel with Colleen and his kids.


Hall Family

Brian Hall
Youth Director 

Brian grew up in Avon Indiana and was saved though the ministry of Pastor Don Tyler of Bethesda Baptist Church.  He graduated from Cincinnati Bible College in 2001 and has since been a member of Calvary working in youth ministries.  His passion for the youth and their parents is that they be grounded in doctrine and knowledge of who they are in Christ Jesus, and join the church in bringing glory to God’s name.  Under his God exalting example, our youth ministries have flourished and are a vibrant blessing to our church.

Brian has been married to his wife Diana since 2007.  They have five children:  Tyson, Caden, Boden, Landon and Brooklyn.

Brian enjoys sports of all kinds (except ones that Diana is better at) and playing with his four boys.


“More and more people, more and more like Jesus”